|
Outdoor Network
Volume VII, Issue 1 - Winter 1996
RISK RELEASES:
A CHECKLIST
by Aaron Goren, Gottlieb & Goren, P.C.
Risk release is a contract to release the right to sue before any incident
occurs. This is different from the more familiar kind of release that
absolves a party from liability, usually by paying a settlement, after
the injury or incident.
The checklist
that follows should be useful in drafting or selecting an appropriate
risk release document. Even if you are already using a risk release, you
should review it for possible improvements. Be aware that many risk release
forms may look sufficient, but upon scrutiny do not really do the job.
Also, be aware that each state decides the legal validity of a risk release
based upon its own law and reasoning. Therefore, the law of the activity
is critical to drafting or selecting a suitable risk release document
CHECKLIST
- Include
a clear statement of who is being released. The protected parties must
be either identified by name or come within the category of person specified.
- Include
a clear statement of who is the releasing party.
- Have the
participant's spouse sign the risk release. A spouse has potential claims
such as reimbursement for medical expenses and loss of care and services
(1).
- Have the
participant agree to indemnify (2) the activity sponsor and its personnel
for actions of the participant.
- Have the
participant agree to indemnify the sponsor and its personnel in the
event of a claim by someone, such as a spouse, who suffers a loss because
the participant was injured. Caution is urged with respect to the use
of an indemnification provision: In some states, a party has no right
to indemnification for its own negligence. Even where an indemnification
clause is enforceable, a court will typically construe the indemnification
obligation under a rule of strict construction against the drafter of
the document. So, the indemnification clause must clearly provide that
it covers the provider's own negligence.
- If a minor
is the participant, have the minor's parent release claims the parent
may have, such as reimbursement for payment of medical expenses. However,
because courts will usually not allow a parent to give up a claim belonging
to a child, a risk release signed by a parent will not release the activity
sponsor from liability to the minor. An indemnification provision in
the risk release signed by the parent will shift liability to the parent.
However, this approach requires careful consideration of applicable
state law.
- State
the activity covered.
- Identify
the types of potential claims that are being released. Types of potential
claims should include negligence (3).
- Potential
claims released should also include gross negligence (4), if allowed
by state law (5).
- Potential
claims released should also include failure to furnish safe equipment,
acts or omissions by employees, ground hazards, etc.
- List the
risks and hazards to the participant. State specifically foreseeable
consequences of the risk of negligence. The description of the risks
and hazards must consider the participant's understanding of the activity.
A thorough recitation of obvious and non-obvious inherent risks is appropriate.
- If a foreseeable
consequence of the risk of negligence includes death, say so.
- If there
may be a limitation to evacuation facilities, state this.
- Have the
participant acknowledge that the use of protective equipment was mandated
or offered for use.
- Give the
participant the opportunity to affirm that he or she is in proper physical
condition to participate in the activity. This provision is appropriate
because the health of the participant may increase the risks and damages
that the participant faces.
- The document
should evidence that the person signing the risk release received the
necessary information to allow him or her to make a knowledgeable and
informed release. Be prepared to show that the person signing the risk
release should have understood the risks and hazards inherent in the
activity as explained in the document.
- The risk
release should be easily readable and in plain English.
- Avoid
fine print
- Emphasize
important points in larger or bold-faced type.
- Use language
that is understandable. Does the document read in understandable (simple
English) terms? Be aware that an agreement is strictly interpreted against
the party that drafted it.
- Resist
the urge to use vague language even if you think that otherwise you
will lose participant interest.
- Include
a plain and clear statement that the signer has read and understands
the document.
- Include
very visible instructions to read the document carefully. Make it your
practice to give the signer ample time to review the document and to
ask any questions about it.
CONCLUSION
It
is prudent for an activity sponsor to require a participant and anyone
who derives a claim from the participant (i.e., a spouse or a parent)
to sign a risk release in advance. However, to be effective, the release
must be properly drafted and signed. Then, the risk release becomes an
important proactive defense to costly claims and litigation.
Aaron VE Coren
has been a member of the State bar of Michigan since 1967 and can be reached
at (810) 352-1880. Mr. Coren urges the reader to consult legal counsel regarding
any points of law. This article should not replace competent legal advice
addressing the reader's own particular needs.
NOTES:
- Depending
on the law of the particular state, the spouse who has not signed a
risk release document may not be able to sue if the participant's spouse
signed a risk release.
- To indemnify
is to shift, by contract, the responsibility for the payment of damages
to someone else
- Negligence
is defined as: The omission to do something which a reasonable man,
guided by those ordinary considerations which ordinarily regulate human
affairs, would do, or the doing of something which a reasonable and
prudent man would not do. (Black's Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition, p.
1032).
-
Gross
negligence is defined as: The intentional failure to perform a manifest
duty in reckless disregard of the consequences as affecting the life
or property of another...(Black's Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition.,
p. 1033).
-
A state
such as Michigan will not permit the contracting away of the risk
of gross negligence (as distinguished from ordinary negligence) as
contrary to public policy
|
|